Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #12588 Reply

    Many teachers say that while learning we should not jump into choose silent violin for learning. They always say that students have to get/improve some skills in acoustic violins first. What are the main reasons behind this say. Is it just the dynamics/bow pressure control to get correct?

    #13471 Reply

    Phil_W
    Participant

    That’s a good question I’m curious as well anyone out there know?

    #13511 Reply

    Dianne Adkins
    Moderator

    I have taught for over 30 years. I have a Master’s of Music in Education, emphasis on violin. Many of my students have gone on to be professionals, teachers and performers, and to major in music in college. All that to say, I can give you my opinion on the matter. An important aspect of violin playing is tone production. Things that effect tone are bow grip, how you use your bow, what the beginning and the end of your bow stroke sounds like (articulation), the weight you put into the bow for full tone, speed of the bow, where the bow contacts the string, dynamics. None of this matters on a silent violin. In fact even if it matters to you, it can’t be properly developed on a silent violin because it can’t produce tonal variation.

    My recommendation is that all violin study should occur on an acoustic violin, so you can master the actual techniques required of the bow arm and hand and learn how what you do with the bow effects the sound. Silent violins are ok for occasional practice with focus on left hand – intonation, shifts, vibrato, sight reading – and only when you’re limited to keeping quiet for the benefit of sleeping roommates or children. You should also practice on a silent (or Im assuming, electric) violin if you’re in a band and will use that instrument in a performance. In that case, you should practice amplified so you know what the audience is going to hear.

    With violin, it’s all about sound. Violins all have different sounds, strings effect sound, bow and how you use it effects sound, rosin type effects sound, the player’s skill effects sound. The sound is the part of playing violin that is totally you, totally unique. If you’re not developing sound, YOUR sound, you’re missing an important aspect of studying the violin. On a grander scheme, your leave out the part of the study or performance that is your expressive ‘essence’.

    The last thing is respect for the music. As musician’s playing music by composers from the 16th, 17th, 18th century; or from a rich historic culture like Jewish, or Arabic, or Eastern, or Scottish or old time Appalachian American… All this music was composed for acoustic instruments. It all requires attention to sound in it’s interpretation. The style of bowing, on or off the string, legato or staccato, loud or soft, soulful or intense vibrato. The composer’s intent, the editor’s suggestions regarding bowings and fingerings, combined with your unique sound, brings forth the full measure of potential in violin performance. When we study violin without this richness in musical spectrum, we starve.

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Check out Michael’s Top Five Favorite Violins at Superior Violins.

    Superior Violins has a selection of Superior Electric Violins. Ask them about financing!

    #13518 Reply

    Phil_W
    Participant

    Wow Diane, thank you for the timely, in depth answer! I was going to get an electric to start off with so i could practice whenever but decided to get an acoustic. Very glad i did now lol

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
Reply To: Silent Electric violin vs Acoustic violin
Your information: