February 16, 2016 at 3:02 pm #13322
So I’m on my own again to improve on violin and I think whatever roadblock I come to, I can get help and answers from this site and want to strive to get better so I can somehow make a living through what I love.
Looking through the advanced lessons on this site, I came across the video talking about the Kreutzer Etudes. I ended up downloading the file this site freely offers and absolutely loved what I saw. I’m sorry, most etudes in the past have bored me and I never seem to finish them. So I just mainly practice scales, arpeggios and performance pieces. Looking at the first etude from Kreutzer, it’s like it involves all your musical senses at once. Bowings, crescendos, rhythms, FINGERINGS! Trills, etc. I’m really excited for these etudes but I want to go about it doing it right. To master the etude in the quickest amont of time and progress to the next.
So I think the best way to go about this is learn the notes first (intonation), then rhythm, after that comes correct bowings, add the trills and grace notes, then finally add in the crescendo and decrescendo written thoughtout the first etude. Is that the best way to go about these etudes?
P.s. The first etude sounds like something Sherlock Holmes would play!February 16, 2016 at 5:37 pm #13326
I have a copy of Kreutzer study #2 which takes you from 1st through 10th position with a 9 page explanation of the exercise. It is in .PDF format. Interested? If you are, send an email to email@example.com with the subject line Niff T. Shift and I’ll get that out to you… if it works.February 16, 2016 at 9:37 pm #13332
Hi Ladbrooke! As far as the process you describe, if you are into the Kreutzer etudes, you shouldn’t have any troubles reading through with most everything in place. Of course, if you are attempting something really hard, I think your break down makes perfect sense, but you may be on one etude for a long time, or not finish it when it gets too hard. I would encourage you to go through the literature in loose order, just so you get all the benefits of fundamentals introduced in earlier etude books. They do sometimes seems boring, but you have to try to think about what you’re supposed to be learning from them.
I don’t know your level of playing, but every student who I give etude books to has to work through the easy ones and progress to the next. Especially if you plan to get a music degree, college teachers will expect that you’ve gone through in an orderly fashion. I’ll try to put an ordered list together sometime, but meanwhile be sure you include technique study books along with an etude book. Here are some ‘staples’ you should be covering before and along with Kreutzer:
Flesch or Galamian Scales and arpeggio studies
Wohlfahrt 60 Etudes Op. 45 Books 1 and 2
Schradieck School of Violin Technique
Sevcik School of Violin Technics, Op. 1
Josephine Trott Melodious Double Stops, Books 1 and 2
F. Mazas Op. 36 Forty Selected Studies
Happy practicing!February 17, 2016 at 4:04 am #13353
Thanks for that list. I can add them to my routine starting tomorrow. I am presently working through the Wohlfahrt and Trott books. However, my teacher has me working with the Barbera Barber “Scales for Advanced Violinists” rather than the Flesch.February 17, 2016 at 4:08 am #13355
I am presently working in the Trott and Wohlfahrt books and my teacher is presently having me work in the Barbara Barber “Scales for Advanced Violinists”.February 17, 2016 at 3:57 pm #13365
A sad truth, most of the teachers I’ve had throughout my life haven’t given me a lot of etudes. Exercises yes, to practice certain techniques but I can’t recall actually going through a book of etudes. I’ve been trying to attempt going through them on my own, but I just don’t get involved in it like I think I should. With the three octave scales, I actually step away from the music stand and close my eyes to listen to sound and intonation, and then look in the mirror to make sure everything else is in order as I play. I’m trying to work at being mentally and physically involved in etudes too because I know they’re just as important as scales, just haven’t been able to maybe until now….
I attempted the first Kreutzer etude and so far everything is coming easily. I like how it’s already taking me into the higher positions and not just on the E string and getting me to try new things. That one I plan on posting here online for criticism as soon as I feel it’s ready to be judged lol
But now I have a nice list to turn to if I end up being humbled by the Kreutzer etudes and/or receive honest criticism from fellow violinist.March 8, 2016 at 5:41 am #13903
learn the notes first (intonation), then rhythm, after that comes correct bowings, add the trills and grace notes, then finally add in the crescendo and decrescendo written throughout the first etude. Is that the best way to go about these etudes.April 22, 2016 at 10:39 pm #15269
I never knew etudes were so important! I have always enjoyed them, so now I have double reasons to practice them
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)